UPDATE: The Scottish Government faces sharp criticism for failing to support a critical Bill aimed at criminalizing the purchase of sex. Leading campaigner Susan Smith of For Women Scotland has called the decision “absolutely shameful,” urging immediate action to protect vulnerable women and combat violence.
The proposed legislation, spearheaded by independent MSP Ash Regan, seeks to impose fines of up to £10,000 or prison sentences on those who buy sex. It follows a landmark victory at the Supreme Court in April 2025, where Smith’s organization successfully challenged the government’s stance. Now, she insists that backing Regan’s Bill presents a crucial opportunity to enact meaningful change.
Community safety minister Siobhian Brown has previously stated that the government “strongly supports the principle” of criminalizing sex buyers but raised “significant concerns” about the current proposals. Critics argue that the Bill could inadvertently push sex workers underground, increasing their risk of harm.
In a passionate response, Smith remarked, “While many pay lip service to tackling violence against women, they shy away from genuine action. The Scottish Government has a unique opportunity to support Ash’s Bill but appears more focused on delaying tactics.” She emphasized, “It is absolutely shameful.”
Regan, the Bill’s proponent, reports a “striking” level of support from key organizations, including Police Scotland and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. She highlighted the backing of specialist women’s organizations and survivors of exploitation, asserting that the proposed reforms align with the government’s Equally Safe strategy to combat violence against women and girls.
“There is deep concern that a government committed to Equally Safe could refuse to act on evidence showing that reducing demand through criminalizing sex buyers leads to measurable improvements in safety,” Regan stated. She added that survivors have expressed overwhelming support for what they see as a “small but critical reform.”
As discussions continue, there is potential for MSPs to be granted a free vote on the so-called “Unbuyable” Bill. Regan insists that women affected by exploitation deserve a Parliament that is willing to engage in serious, constructive dialogue on these pressing issues.
In response to mounting pressure, a Scottish Government spokesperson affirmed, “The victims minister has made it clear that we support the criminalization of the purchasing of sex.” However, they reiterated that the Bill, being a private member’s initiative, requires significant amendments to ensure it has the confidence of Parliament, particularly regarding women’s safety.
The urgency of this matter is palpable, with advocates urging immediate action from the Scottish Government. As the debate unfolds, the implications for community safety and the protection of vulnerable populations are at the forefront of public concern.
Stay tuned for further updates on this developing story as the Scottish Government faces increasing pressure to act decisively on this critical legislation.
