UPDATE: Fans are in uproar after Ariana Grande lost the Best Supporting Actress award to Amy Madigan at the Critics Choice Awards held on January 4, 2026, in Santa Monica. Grande, nominated for her role as Glinda in Wicked: For Good, faced a shocking defeat as Madigan took home the coveted honor for her performance in the horror film Weapons.
Ariana Grande’s supporters flooded social media, expressing their outrage at what many deemed a “robbery.” “The wrong witch won!” declared one fan, echoing sentiments shared widely online as the news broke. Grande, who has been celebrated for her performance in the blockbuster adaptation of the Broadway hit, was nominated for the second consecutive year but fell short as Madigan’s role as the antagonistic Aunt Gladys captured the award.
The tension was palpable in the room as Madigan, visibly surprised, accepted her award. “I really wasn’t expecting all of this,” she remarked to the audience. Fans quickly took to Twitter, with one user mirroring Kanye West’s infamous VMAs interruption, tweeting, “AMY MADIGAN IMA LET YOU FINISH BUT ARIANA GRANDE HAD THE BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS PERFORMANCE!!!”
Grande, alongside fellow nominees including Elle Fanning and Teyana Taylor, cheered Madigan on as she made her way to the stage, showcasing a show of unity despite the competitive atmosphere. “This award belongs to ARI!!!!” tweeted another fan, calling for a rebound at the upcoming Golden Globes.
The Critics Choice Awards, often seen as a pivotal indicator for future award seasons, spotlighted Grande’s film alongside others like Sinners and One Battle After Another, which each garnered critical acclaim and numerous nominations. The awards ceremony serves as a significant launchpad for nominees looking to build momentum heading into the Oscars.
As the dust settles from this upset, fans are left eagerly anticipating the Golden Globe Awards on January 11. Will Grande reclaim the spotlight? This loss has ignited conversations about the unpredictability of awards season and the fierce competition among Hollywood’s elite.
Stay tuned as we continue to cover the fallout from the Critics Choice Awards and the upcoming Golden Globes. The conversation surrounding this year’s nominees and winners is far from over, with fans and industry insiders alike weighing in on the implications of these results.
