Plans for an artificial sports pitch at Brighton, Hove and Sussex VI Form College (BHASVIC) are facing significant opposition from local residents concerned about environmental impacts. A public meeting attended by over 30 individuals highlighted worries about biodiversity loss and the effect of proposed floodlights on local wildlife, such as insects, birds, and bats.
During the meeting, Steve Geliot, vice-chair of the local environmental group, expressed alarm over light pollution caused by the proposed 4,000k floodlights. He stated, “We are highlighting the biodiversity impacts, the light pollution, the detrimental visual impacts on Dyke Road Park due to 4.5-metre steel fencing and 10-metre-high light columns.” Geliot emphasized that while the college plans to mitigate biodiversity loss by purchasing biodiversity net gain (BNG) credits from the Iford estate, it effectively exports biodiversity away from the city.
Geliot also referenced the findings of ecologist Graeme Lyons, who has recorded approximately 500 species in the field, including 11 species with conservation status. Concerns were further raised by the Friends of the Park, who pointed out that similar sports facilities are already available at the nearby Cardinal Newman Catholic School. They questioned the necessity of additional facilities, arguing that the benefits would primarily extend to elite sports teams, rather than providing broader sporting qualifications for students.
Noise concerns also emerged, particularly due to the proximity of the Brighton Open Air Theatre. In response, BHASVIC has conducted further noise tests to address these issues.
In defense of the project, William Baldwin, principal of BHASVIC, asserted that the development would lead to a net gain in biodiversity, as documented in the planning materials. “We have completed extensive ecological surveys in order to submit our plans with appropriate mitigations in place to minimize the impact of this work,” Baldwin stated. He highlighted the college’s commitment to enhancing local biodiversity and maintaining a collaborative relationship with the Friends of the Field.
Baldwin also noted the college’s sports programs, which include A-level Physical Education and various BTEC pathways. He mentioned that BHASVIC’s ladies’ football academy reached the semi-finals of the National Colleges Cup and the netball academy advanced to the finals of the National Schools U-19 competition, showcasing the college’s sporting achievements. Currently, students must travel off-site for practical training and matches, underscoring the need for improved facilities.
As of now, there are 1,350 objections and 78 supporting comments on the application listed on the Brighton and Hove City Council website. Those interested in reviewing the application or providing feedback can do so by searching for BH2025/02901 on the council’s site.
The ongoing debate reflects a broader community engagement with local environmental issues and the balance between development and conservation.
