Labour MP John McDonnell has indicated that Prime Minister Keir Starmer might choose to resign rather than be ousted from his position. McDonnell’s comments come amid mounting speculation regarding Starmer’s leadership as Labour’s popularity has significantly declined in recent months.
During a visit to Yash Raj Films in Mumbai, India, on October 8, 2025, Starmer’s administration has faced increased scrutiny, particularly as local elections in May are expected to be a critical juncture for his leadership. Polls suggest that Labour may suffer losses in councils across England and potentially lose control over devolved governments in Wales and Scotland.
Potential Leadership Contenders Emerge
There is speculation that several prominent figures within the party could vie for leadership if Starmer steps down. Key names mentioned include Wes Streeting, the current health secretary; former deputy prime minister Angela Rayner; Andy Burnham, the mayor of Manchester; and home secretary Shabana Mahmood. These individuals are seen as potential successors should the party decide to move in a new direction.
McDonnell, who previously served as shadow chancellor, suggested that Starmer might proactively step down if the May elections yield disappointing results for the party. When asked about Starmer’s position a year from now, McDonnell stated, “I’m like anybody else really, we will see what happens over the next six months.” He emphasized that while a coup was not likely, Starmer would need to consider his future based on the election outcomes.
Assessing Party Dynamics and Public Sentiment
Reflecting on Starmer’s character, McDonnell noted, “He’s a serious politician, he’s a serious person and he’s a responsible person.” He believes that if the May elections are as detrimental as predicted, Starmer will make an informed decision about his leadership role. “If he doesn’t think he is the right person for the job, he’ll stand down,” McDonnell added.
In the past, Starmer has expressed doubts about his leadership, particularly following the Labour Party’s poor performance in the 2021 local elections. He admitted to contemplating resignation during that period, acknowledging that his inability to drive change might warrant a leadership transition. “I did consider quitting because I didn’t feel that I should be bigger than the party,” Starmer told Sky News last year.
Despite the current challenges, McDonnell believes that the Labour government has opportunities to regain public trust. He urged the party to avoid “repeating the same mistakes of the past” and to demonstrate stability by effectively addressing pressing issues such as the ongoing cost of living crisis. “If they demonstrated a steadiness in government and addressing the real issues that people are facing, I think there’s a prospect we could turn things around,” he remarked.
As the Labour Party braces for the upcoming May elections, the focus on Starmer’s leadership and the potential for a shift in direction remains a subject of intense discussion within political circles. The next few months will be pivotal in shaping the future of Labour and its leadership.
