Pembrokeshire County Council has decided to pause its proposed £40 million road realignment scheme in Newgale, a move welcomed by local Senedd Member Paul Davies. The decision follows a history of severe flooding in the area, notably after storms in early 2014 and Storm Dennis in 2020, which prompted significant community concern and governmental attention.
The council’s Cabinet discussed the project during a recent meeting, where they received an update from Councillor Rhys Sinnett. The proposed scheme, part of the Newgale Coastal Adaptation Project, aimed to develop a new inland section of the A487 road, approximately 2.3 kilometers from the coast, replacing the vulnerable coastal route. The initiative was set to undergo a formal application process with the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park.
Various estimates for the scheme’s costs have circulated, ranging from £20 million to as much as £60 million. Significant expenditure on consultation fees had already occurred, further complicating the financial landscape. In light of these costs and the urgent need for a solution, the Cabinet presented several options, including a formal submission, abandonment, or the preferred choice of pausing for 18 to 24 months.
During the meeting, the Cabinet acknowledged the necessity of the scheme due to ongoing climate change and previous work completed. Nevertheless, they emphasized the importance of reassessing the situation, given the current financial climate and immediate risks to the A487. The Council plans to continue monitoring the area while exploring short-term improvements to address flooding impacts.
A community-led alternative proposed by the organization STUN (Stand Up for Newgale) offers a potentially less disruptive solution. Their plan involves realigning the shingle bank at Newgale seaward, creating an over-wash barrier to capture sea water and pebbles, which could be a more cost-effective approach.
Mr. Davies expressed his satisfaction with the Cabinet’s decision, urging the Council to consider the community’s proposal seriously. He stated, “Coastal erosion in Newgale has been a longstanding issue, and it’s crucial that any response is both effective and proportionate. The community has developed its own Newgale Beach Access and Shingle Bank Realignment Scheme, which offers a less invasive approach that would significantly reduce costs.”
The Cabinet’s resolution to pause the scheme reflects a growing recognition of the need for balanced solutions that address environmental concerns, financial responsibilities, and the needs of local residents. The next steps will involve a careful review of the situation in the coming months, keeping in mind the long-term objectives for coastal protection and community safety.
